The LCMS Large Catechism Controversy | A Post Mortem

Recently, The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod published a Large Catechism with Annotations and Commentary applications. That publication came under heavy controversy and was pulled from publication and within a week was re-issued with no changes. This video serves as a post mortem for the controversy and my thoughts on what has happened.

Share This Episode

Last week, the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (LCMS) became embroiled in controversy over the publication of a new Annotated Large Catechism by Concordia Publishing House (CPH). The book, which included essays and commentary alongside Luther’s Large Catechism text, drew criticism from some LCMS laymen who felt that certain passages promoted views at odds with Biblical and confessional Lutheranism, such as critical race theory, opposition to self-defense, denial of concupiscence, and improper roles for women.

In response, LCMS President Rev. Dr. Matthew C. Harrison initially requested that CPH pause distribution of the book in order to review the concerns. However, after about a week, President Harrison issued a statement saying that while some things could have been expressed more clearly, there was “nothing in the content of the volume promoting critical race theory (CRT), confusion of sexual issues or any theological position at odds with biblical and confessional Lutheranism.”

The Annotated Large Catechism has now been re-released, but the incident raises some troubling questions. While President Harrison claims that the book went through proper doctrinal review, it seems clear that at minimum, the controversial passages were worded ambiguously enough to cause widespread confusion and concern among laymen. If a resource meant to help teach and apply Lutheran doctrine to contemporary issues cannot do so clearly, that is a problem.

Even more concerning was President Harrison’s strong condemnation of the “unchristian attacks” made by those who raised the alarm about the book. A 3-hour discussion by concerned LCMS laymen thoughtfully critiqued the problematic essays, acknowledging the best construction one could put on them while still finding them severely lacking in clarity. These measured critiques were a far cry from “unchristian attacks.” To invite thoughtful criticism while at the same time demonizing those who offered it reveals a troubling double standard.

As a Lutheran in a different church body, I grieve for my friends in the LCMS who are discouraged by this turn of events. But it points to a hard reality – being in fellowship with church leadership that privileges institutional bylaws over clear biblical teaching, or that seems beholden to academic fads and cultural pressures more than faithful Lutheran doctrine, is untenable. There comes a point where one must assess whether they can, in good conscience, remain in communion with such a church body.

My intention is not to make that decision for anyone else, but simply to soberly reflect on the takeaways from this regrettable saga. I encourage everyone to thoughtfully review the evidence for themselves and consider what faithfulness looks like in their context. Above all, may Christ’s church be led by His Word alone as we await His return.

Join the Conversation

New episodes release regularly, featuring discussions on theology, church history, current events, and the intersection of faith and culture. Whether you’re a theology student, a pastor, or simply someone interested in deeper theological discussion, you’ll find content that challenges, entertains, and edifies.

Disclaimer: I am a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Diocese of North America and, unless otherwise stated, my opinions are my own and I do not speak as a representative for my Diocese. That is what my Bishop is for. For more information on the ELDoNA visit eldona.org

More Episodes

Ep. 80: 5th Annual Synod and Colloquium Special!

Ep. 80: 5th Annual Synod and Colloquium Special!

Podcast Episodes

Welcome to The Bookcase Behind Me — where books aren’t just background, they’re battlegrounds of faith, doctrine, and truth. This is the show where Confessional Lutheran voices speak boldly from behind the pulpit, the lectern, and yes — the bookcase — to equip today’s Church for tomorrow’s trials.

In each theologically rich episode, we bring you uncompromising conversations with Lutheran leaders rooted in Scripture, shaped by history, and aimed at building up Christ’s Church for generations to come.

📚 This episode features:

  • Pastor John Rutowicz on the Lutheran Rite of Exorcism — uncovering the biblical authority and liturgical depth behind this rarely discussed but deeply pastoral practice.

  • Pastor Martin Jackson on Translation Work — a look into the sacred task of bringing the teachings of the Word of God into new tongues without losing its theological integrity.

  • Deacon Anthony Oncken on the 1700th Anniversary of the Council of Nicaea — exploring how the Nicene Creed still shapes the true Church amid modern heresies.

  • Pastor Eric Stefanski tackling the Nature of the Being of God and Man — engaging with classical metaphysics to answer who God is and who we are before Him.

  • Bishop James Heiser introduces his new book “A Time to Stand” — a call for Christians to reclaim their Christian vocation and identity as a means of forming a bold, faithful generation in an age of compromise. Buy it now on Amazon: https://a.co/d/frBBrrt 

Whether you’re a pastor, seminarian, lay theologian, or curious listener with a worn-out Book of Concord and a shelf full of dogmatics, The Bookcase Behind Me delivers clear teaching, unapologetic Lutheranism, and serious discussion to strengthen your faith and sharpen your confession.

🎧 Subscribe now and rediscover what it means to stand firm — with the right books behind you and the truth before you.

Subscribe ➜ http://bit.ly/1UZjzXi

Donate at https://streamlabs.com/brandonwarr/tip

Follow me on Twitter, Instagram, and Parler @RevBWarr

Join “The Bookcase Behind Me” on Facebook: 

https://www.facebook.com/thebookcasebehindme

Disclaimer: I am a member of the Evangelical Lutheran Diocese of North America and, unless otherwise stated, my opinions are my own and I do not speak as a representative for my Diocese. That is what my Bishop is for. For more information on the ELDoNA visit eldona.org

 

 


Ep. 77: Wesley Huff vs. Billy Carson: a Quick Debate Review

Ep. 77: Wesley Huff vs. Billy Carson: a Quick Debate Review

Podcast Episodes

A quick review of the Debate between Christian Scholar Wesley Huff and Conspiracy Peddlar Billy Carson. This quick review is just to get some thoughts out and encourage the listener to dive into apologetics with their Pastor and Church in a fruitful and Christ-centered way.

Links to videos mentioned:

The Full Debate: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7ngjtT43-4&t=6056s

The Joe Rogan Episode with Wesley Huff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwyAX69xG1Q&t=6583s

Ep. 75: St. Patrick of Ireland, Pagan Red Pillers, and Enjoying Hobbies

Ep. 75: St. Patrick of Ireland, Pagan Red Pillers, and Enjoying Hobbies

Podcast Episodes

On today’s episode, Pastor Warr discusses the life and doctrine of St. Patrick of Ireland. This episode also introduces a new segment on the goings on of the week as Pastor Warr discusses the deception of the Modern Red Pill movement, Proverbs 31 and Femininity, as well as how to enjoy your hobbies as Christian.

 

Scroll to Top